Content Comparison

Requires : removing the FIU from the AO Bench

to gain access to detector.

None

• Would not be able to guide on a star with the accuracy required for radial velocity measurements.

Cal Unit

Octagon Stepper Motor

Thorlabs NR360S

1x

$2,700

If it failed out-of-beam:

• We would not be able to calibrate the main spectrometer and monitor instrument drift.

If it failed in-beam:

• Light from the telescope would be blocked.

FIU

Guide Detector

First Light
Advanced Imagery
C-RED 2

1x

$39k /
6 weeks

The rotation stage is accessible on the outside of the Calibration Bench, and mechanically this is a straightforward change. The difficulty lies in re-aligning the fold mirror mounted on the rotation stage, so that is directs the light from all sources onto the various fibers.

None

Requires removing the FIU from the AO Bench to gain access to detector.

None

• Would not be able to guide on a star with the accuracy required for radial velocity measurements.

Ca HK

Ca HK Detector

Andor Newton 920 (with UV-optimized CCD)

1x

• At best this would allow use of only one calibration source.

• However, it would likely take the entire Calibration Unit off-line

• We would not be able to calibrate the main spectrometer and monitor instrument drift.

Cal Unit

Shutters

Uniblitz DSS25B

6x

(2x Cal Bench,
1x Flat Field, 2x SoCal,
1x HK)

$540 ea /
4-5 weeks

Requires opening Ca HK Spectrometer (after swinging it to a horizontal state).

The various shutters are designed to be easily removable from their mounts. Marked as medium difficulty given time required to open the enclosure to access shutter, and care required while working around exposed optics and fibers.

Consumable item.

3 spares

If the Calibration shutters fail:

• Ca HK Spectrometer would not be usable if detector failed.

• Main spectrometer and rest of system We would no longer be able to calibrate the main spectrometer or track instrument drift.

If the SoCal, HK Spectrometer, or Flat Field Fiber shutters fail:

• The main spectrometer would be unaffected.

Cal Unit

Octagon Stepper Motor

Thorlabs NR360SFiber System

Scrambler Timed Shutter

Uniblitz NS65B

1x$2

$1,700 StatuscolourRedtitlevery difficult280 /
4-5 weeks

The rotation stage is accessible on the outside of the Calibration Bench, and mechanically this is a straightforward change. The difficulty lies in re-aligning the fold mirror mounted on the rotation stage, so that is directs the light from all sources onto the various fibers.

None

This shutter is designed to be easily removable from the scrambler. Marked as medium difficulty given time required to open the enclosure to access the shutter, and care required while working around exposed optics and fibers.

Consumable item.

1 spare

• At best this would allow use of only one calibration source.

• However, it would likely take the entire Calibration Unit off-line

• We would not be able to calibrate the main spectrometer and monitor instrument drift.

Cal Unit

ThAr Lamp

Green Scientific G858A

2x

(1x Daily,
1x 'Gold')

• This shutter controls the exposure time of the main spectrometer. Would not be able to take spectra until shutter is replaced.

Vac Cart

Turbo Pump

Leybold TurboVac 450iX

1x

$7,700

The lamps are easily accessible on the exterior of the Calibration Unit.

Consumable item.

1 spare

Vacuum chamber gate valve must be closed, and Vac Cart enclosure opened to replace pump. Vacuum pressure within chamber will be rising during this time (affecting instrumental stability), making this replacement time-sensitive. A WMKO turbo cart could be connected to the chamber during the replacement to help minimize the vacuum pressure change.

None

Cal Unit

Broadband Source 

Thorlabs SLS201L

2x

(1x Octagon, 1x Flat Field)

$1,200
No lead (June 2023)

The broadband sources are easily accessible under the Calibration Bench.

Consumable item.

None

• Would lose some calibration ability but could rely on past calibrations until replacement available. (True?)

Cal Unit

Intensity Monitor Stage

Newmark MSL-50-21

1x

• we can rely on the other lamp of the same type until replacement arrives.

If both lamps of the same type fail:

• we lose ability to wavelength-calibrate daily, and will have to rely on past calibrations. Radial velocity precision might be impacted.

Cal Unit

UNe Lamp

Photron P863

2x

(1x Daily,
1x 'Gold')

$825

The lamps are easily accessible on the exterior of the Calibration Unit.

Consumable item.

4 spares

Cal Unit

HCL Power Supply

Photron P209 Hollow Cathode Lamp Power Supply

and

Green Scientific G200

4x

(1x Th-Ar Daily,
1x Th-Ar Gold,

1x U-Ne Daily, 1x Un-Ne Gold)

Green Scientific Supply:

$730

The HCL power supplies are easily accessible within the Calibration Rack.

1x Green Scientific Power Supply

If one supply fails:

• we can rely on the other lamp of the same type until replacement arrives.

If two supplies of the same type fail:

• we could swap supplies around to have one lamp of each type operational until replacement arrives.

If three supplies fail:

• we lose ability to wavelength-calibrate daily, and will have to rely on past calibrations. Radial velocity precision might be impacted.

• Chamber would start to lose vacuum pressure

• During time required to obtain replacement pump, vacuum pressure would rise significantly and reset the instrumental stability time series.

Vac Cart

Roots Pump

Leybold EcoDry 65 Plus

1x

$9,600

Vacuum chamber gate valve must be closed, and Vac Cart enclosure opened to replace pump. Vacuum pressure within chamber will be rising during this time (affecting instrumental stability), making this replacement time-sensitive. A WMKO turbo cart could be connected to the chamber during the replacement to help minimize the vacuum pressure change.

None

• Chamber would start to lose vacuum pressure

• During time required to obtain replacement pump, vacuum pressure would rise significantly and reset the instrumental stability time series.

Aux Rack

LN2 Pumps

Instec LN2-SYS

2x

The pumps are easily accessible on the LN2 cart in the basement. Marked as medium difficulty given the steps involved:

• power down the appropriate Instec controller;

• connect the new pump and power it on;

• turn the Instec controller back on;

• ensure Instec set point is correct and temperature control enabled.

There is also some risk involved, as care must be taken to avoid water vapor getting into the lines (leading to ice blocking the lines). If ice blocks the lines then the CCD must be warmed up and the lines purged (with a major disruption to the instrument stability timeline).

1 brand-new spare;
1 used spare

• CCD thermal control cannot be maintained with the LN2 pump running. The CCD will start to warm up.

Aux Rack

Cryostat Ion Pumps

Gamma 3SDI1V5KNN (3S TiTan)

4x

$770 /
6-7 weeks

Requires warming up CCDs, venting main spectrometer vacuum chamber, and removing the large camera-access flange on the side of the vacuum chamber. The ion pumps can be “re-conditioned” at WMKO and re-used.

500 hours at 1e-4mbar

5,000 hours at 1e-5mbar

50,000 hours at 1e-6mbar

500,000 hours at 1e-7mbar

None

Each cryostat has two ion pumps.

• If one fails:

  Status
  colour Green title small impact

• If both fail:

  Status
  colour Red title major impact

  • CCD thermal control will be lost

Aux Rack

Instec Controller

Instec mK2000B

2

$5000 / 4-6 weeks

Mechanically the stage is easy to remove, and the intensity monitor detector is simply mounted (on a post with no careful alignment requirements). Marked as medium difficulty given the care required to avoid damaging the bare optical fibers within the Calibration Unit enclosure.

None

• If stage failed out-of-beam, it could stay there until replaced.

• If stage failed in-beam, it could be removed from system until replacement is available.

Cal Unit

Filter Wheel

Thorlabs FW102C

3x

(1x Octagon, 1x Flat Field)

The pumps are easily accessible on the LN2 cart in the basement. Marked as medium difficulty given the software steps involved:

• power down the appropriate Instec controller and disconnect cables;

• connect the new controller and power it on;

• ensure Instec set point is correct and temperature control enabled.

1 spare has been ordered

• CCD thermal control cannot be maintained without the Instec system running. The CCD will start to warm up.

FIU

H&K Fiber Stage

Micronix PPX-32CR-C0002

1x

$4,500 ea / 10-12 weeks

Requires:

• removing FIU from AO Bench,

• opening FIU,

• removing Ca HK fibers from stage,

• removing stage from FIU.

None

Mechanically the filter wheels are easy to remove with no careful alignment requirements. Marked as medium difficulty given the care required to avoid damaging the bare optical fibers within the Calibration Unit enclosure.

None

• Throughput of Ca HK spectrometer would diminish, likely to a point were spectra do not have enough flux to be useful.

• Main spectrometer and rest of system would be unaffected.

Ca HK

Ca HK Detector

Andor Newton 920 (with UV-optimized CCD)

1x

$37k / 12 weeks

Exposure Meter

Exposure Meter Detector

SBIG Aluma 47-10

1x

$15k /
6-8 weeks

Requires opening the Exposure Meter enclosure. Detector is on mounting that is designed to be removable.

None

• Main spectrometer would remain operational, however, ability to monitor flux within science exposures would be lost. RV quality would suffer because precise exposure midtimes could not be computed.

LFC

PCF Fiber

Menlo Systems

1

Brett Smith (WMKO) installed the replacement when the PCF fiber failed. He said it took about an hour, but one needs to be slow and methodical. Covers, module, output fibers are removed one of which, the IR, is in a tight space. PCF module location is set by pins.

Consumable item.

None

• Would require a change in calibration strategy (and scripts) but could likely carry on until replacement filter wheel arrived.

Cal Unit

Compensator Motor

Newport TRA12PPD

4x
(2x BS,
2x Fold)

Need TBD

Cal Unit

Shutters

Uniblitz DSS25B

6x

(2x Cal Bench,
1x Flat Field, 2x SoCal,
1x HK)

$540 ea /
4-5 weeks

The various shutters are designed to be easily removable from their mounts. Marked as medium difficulty given time required to open the enclosure to access shutter, and care required while working around exposed optics and fibers.

Consumable item.

3 spares

If the Calibration shutters fail:

• We would no longer be able to calibrate the main spectrometer or track instrument drift.

If the SoCal, HK Spectrometer, or Flat Field Fiber shutters fail:

• The main spectrometer would be unaffected.

Cal Unit 

Etalon Super Continuum

NKT SuperK EVO

1x

$33.5k for new device, $8.5k to refurbish existing device. Lead time: 4-6 weeks.

The SuperK is easily accessible within Etalon Rack.

Consumable item.

None

• If etalon not available, calibrations will have to lean more heavily on the LFC and the HCL lamps.

• Using the LFC instead of the etalon is more expensive, as it leads to more frequent PCF fiber replacements in the LFC.

Requires opening Ca HK Spectrometer (after swinging it to a horizontal state).

None

• Ca HK Spectrometer would not be usable if detector failed.

• Main spectrometer and rest of system would be unaffected.

Cal Unit

Broadband Source 

Thorlabs SLS201L

2x

(1x Octagon, 1x Flat Field)

$1,200
No lead (June 2023)

The broadband sources are easily accessible under the Calibration Bench.

Consumable item.

None

• Would lose some calibration ability but could rely on past calibrations until replacement available. (True?)

Cal Unit

ThAr Lamp

Green Scientific G858A

2x

(1x Daily,
1x 'Gold')

$405

The lamps are easily accessible on the exterior of the Calibration Unit.

Consumable item.

1 spare

If one lamp fails:

• we can rely on the other lamp of the same type until replacement arrives.

If both lamps of the same type fail:

• we lose ability to wavelength-calibrate daily, and will have to rely on past calibrations. Radial velocity precision might be impacted.

Cal Unit

UNe Lamp

Photron P863

2x

(1x Daily,
1x 'Gold')

$825

The lamps are easily accessible on the exterior of the Calibration Unit.

Consumable item.

4 spares

Cal Unit

HCL Power Supply

Photron P209 Hollow Cathode Lamp Power Supply

and

Green Scientific G200

4x

(1x Th-Ar Daily,
1x Th-Ar Gold,

1x U-Ne Daily, 1x Un-Ne Gold)

Green Scientific Supply:

$730

The HCL power supplies are easily accessible within the Calibration Rack.

1x Green Scientific Power Supply

If one supply fails:

• we can rely on the other lamp of the same type until replacement arrives.

If two supplies of the same type fail:

• we could swap supplies around to have one lamp of each type operational until replacement arrives.

If three supplies fail:

• LFC cannot be used until replaced. Calibrations we lose ability to wavelength-calibrate daily, and will have to lean more heavily on the etalon and the HCL lamps while LFC down; could compromise tracking of instrument stability

Fiber System

Scrambler Timed Shutter

Uniblitz NS65B

1x

• rely on past calibrations. Radial velocity precision might be impacted.

Cal Unit

Filter Wheel

Thorlabs FW102C

3x

(1x Octagon, 1x Flat Field)

$1,300
No lead (June 2023)

This shutter is designed to be easily removable from the scramblerMechanically the filter wheels are easy to remove with no careful alignment requirements. Marked as medium difficulty given time the care required to open the enclosure to access the shutter, and care required while working around exposed optics and fibers.

Consumable item.

1 spare

avoid damaging the bare optical fibers within the Calibration Unit enclosure.

None

• This shutter controls the exposure time of the main spectrometer. Would not be able to take spectra until shutter is replaced.

Fiber System

Scrambler Source Select Shutter

Uniblitz RS20B

2x

• Would require a change in calibration strategy (and scripts) but could likely carry on until replacement filter wheel arrived.

Cal Unit

Compensator Motor

Newport TRA12PPD

4x
(2x BS,
2x Fold)

Need TBD

Cal Unit 

Etalon Super Continuum

NKT SuperK EVO

1x

$33.5k for new device, $8.5k to refurbish existing device. Lead time: 4-6 weeks.

These shutters are designed to be easily removable from the scrambler. Marked as medium difficulty given time required to open the enclosure to access the shutters, and care required while working around exposed optics and fibers.

Consumable item.

The SuperK is easily accessible within Etalon Rack.

Consumable item.

None

• If one of these shutters fails in a closed state, that light path (Science or Sky) cannot be used until the shutter is replaced.

Fiber System

Agitator Motor

Galil BLM-N23-50-1000-B

1x

$500 /
1-2 weeks
(in 2018)

• etalon not available, calibrations will have to lean more heavily on the LFC and the HCL lamps.

• Using the LFC instead of the etalon is more expensive, as it leads to more frequent PCF fiber replacements in the LFC.

Exposure Meter

Exposure Meter Detector

SBIG Aluma 47-10

1x

$15k /
6-8 weeks

Motor is accessible on the outside of the agitator. A flex coupling is used between the motor and the agitator mechanism, so no careful alignment required. Marked as medium difficulty given the agitator is located within the crypt (not easily accessible and potential permits required).

Requires opening the Exposure Meter enclosure. Detector is on mounting that is designed to be removable.

None

• Observations could continue however the radial velocity precision will be impacted.

Vac Cart

Turbo Pump

Leybold TurboVac 450iX

1x

$7,700

• Main spectrometer would remain operational, however, ability to monitor flux within science exposures would be lost. RV quality would suffer because precise exposure midtimes could not be computed.

LFC

PCF Fiber

Menlo Systems

1

Vacuum chamber gate valve must be closed, and Vac Cart enclosure opened to replace pump. Vacuum pressure within chamber will be rising during this time (affecting instrumental stability), making this replacement time-sensitive. A WMKO turbo cart could be connected to the chamber during the replacement to help minimize the vacuum pressure change.

None

• Chamber would start to lose vacuum pressure

• During time required to obtain replacement pump, vacuum pressure would rise significantly and reset the instrumental stability time series.

Vac Cart

Roots Pump

Leybold EcoDry 65 Plus

1x

$9,600

Vacuum chamber gate valve must be closed, and Vac Cart enclosure opened to replace pump. Vacuum pressure within chamber will be rising during this time (affecting instrumental stability), making this replacement time-sensitive. A WMKO turbo cart could be connected to the chamber during the replacement to help minimize the vacuum pressure change.

None

• Chamber would start to lose vacuum pressure

• During time required to obtain replacement pump, vacuum pressure would rise significantly and reset the instrumental stability time series.

Vac Cart

Isolator Stepper Motors

Lin Engineering 4118M-06S-22RO

5x

Requires warming up CCDs, venting main spectrometer vacuum chamber, and opening chamber door(s) to gain access to the motors under the optical bench. Depending on the motor’s location, the Vac Cart, Aux Rack and LN2 Autofill system might need to be disconnected and moved out of the way so the chamber door can open.

Brett Smith (WMKO) installed the replacement when the PCF fiber failed. He said it took about an hour, but one needs to be slow and methodical. Covers, module, output fibers are removed one of which, the IR, is in a tight space. PCF module location is set by pins.

Consumable item.

None

• Loss of one motor could likely be compensated for through adjustment of the other four.

• It is very unlikely we would vent the chamber only to replace one of these motors.

Aux Rack

Cryostat Ion Pumps

Gamma 3SDI1V5KNN (3S TiTan)

4x

• LFC cannot be used until replaced. Calibrations will have to lean more heavily on the etalon and the HCL lamps while LFC down; could compromise tracking of instrument stability

Fiber System

Scrambler Source Select Shutter

Uniblitz RS20B

2x

$550 each (minimum quantity was 10 last time we ordered). Lead time: 5-6 weeks

Requires warming up CCDs, venting main spectrometer vacuum chamber, and removing the large camera-access flange on the side of the vacuum chamber. The ion pumps can be “re-conditioned” at WMKO and re-used.

500 hours at 1e-4mbar

5,000 hours at 1e-5mbar

50,000 hours at 1e-6mbar

500,000 hours at 1e-7mbar

None

Each cryostat has two ion pumps.

• If one fails:

  Status
  colour Green title small impact

• If both fail:

  Status
  colour Red title major impact

  • CCD thermal control will be lost

Aux Rack

LN2 Pumps

Instec LN2-SYS

2x

These shutters are designed to be easily removable from the scrambler. Marked as medium difficulty given time required to open the enclosure to access the shutters, and care required while working around exposed optics and fibers.

Consumable item.

10 spares

• If one of these shutters fails in a closed state, that light path (Science or Sky) cannot be used until the shutter is replaced.

Fiber System

Agitator Motor

Galil BLM-N23-50-1000-B

1x

$500 /
1-2 weeks
(in 2018)

Motor is accessible on the outside of the agitator. A flex coupling is used between the motor and the agitator mechanism, so no careful alignment required. Marked as medium difficulty given the agitator is located within the crypt (not easily accessible and potential permits required).

None

Aux Rack

Instec Controller

Instec mK2000B

2

The pumps are easily accessible on the LN2 cart in the basement. Marked as medium difficulty given the steps involved:

• power down the appropriate Instec controller;

• connect the new pump and power it on;

• turn the Instec controller back on;

• ensure Instec set point is correct and temperature control enabled.

There is also some risk involved, as care must be taken to avoid water vapor getting into the lines (leading to ice blocking the lines). If ice blocks the lines then the CCD must be warmed up and the lines purged (with a major disruption to the instrument stability timeline).

1 brand-new spare;
1 used spare

• CCD thermal control cannot be maintained with the LN2 pump running. The CCD will start to warm up.

• Observations could continue however the radial velocity precision will be impacted.

Vac Cart

Isolator Stepper Motors

Lin Engineering 4118M-06S-22RO

5x

Requires warming up CCDs, venting main spectrometer vacuum chamber, and opening chamber door(s) to gain access to the motors under the optical bench. Depending on the motor’s location, the Vac Cart, Aux Rack and LN2 Autofill system might need to be disconnected and moved out of the way so the chamber door can open.

Used very infrequently (mainly for initial alignment of bench or realigning after a significant earthquake). Powered off when not in use.

None

• Loss of one motor could likely be compensated for through adjustment of the other four.

• It is very unlikely we would vent the chamber only to replace one of these motors.

Cal Unit

Intensity Monitor Stage

Newmark MSL-50-21

1x

$1,100

Mechanically the stage is easy to remove, and the intensity monitor detector is simply mounted (on a post with no careful alignment requirements). Marked as medium difficulty given the

• power down the appropriate Instec controller and disconnect cables;

• connect the new controller and power it on;

• ensure Instec set point is correct and temperature control enabled.

care required to avoid damaging the bare optical fibers within the Calibration Unit enclosure.

None

• If stage failed out-of-beam, it could stay there until replaced.

• If stage failed in-beam, it could be removed from system until replacement is available.

LN2 Cart

Autofill Solenoids

2x

Have asked John Valiant for details